Special Order Cakes

We would love to make a custom special order cake or cupcakes for you! Please prepare for ordering your cake by taking a look at the following step by step guide. We request 7 days notice for special orders, but are happy to accommodate quicker orders when possible. Call us at 614.784.2253 to check availability and to place your order.

Need to pick up a cake today or tomorrow? We have a selection of ready to go 6” cakes in our cake cooler. Please stop in to see what we have available or give us a call!

step 1 - let's get started with some basic information

Let us know some details about your order! When you call, we'll need to know the following information to get started:

Pick up date and time
Full name
Phone number
Food allergies

step 2 - choose your cake or cupcake flavor

Our flavors are organized into classic and deluxe categories. You can mix and match classic and deluxe for the cake flavor and icing flavor. If you select a deluxe flavor for either the cake or icing, the cake will be priced as a deluxe cake.

Classic cake flavors

almond, caramel, chocolate, coconut, hazelnut, lemon, mint, orange, spice, vanilla

Deluxe cake flavors

apple butter, banana, blackberry, black tea, blueberry, cardamom rosewater, carrot (with or without walnuts), chai, cherry, coffee, green tea, lavender, lemon poppyseed, lime, lime coconut, mango, maple, marble, peach, peanut butter, pineapple, pistachio rosewater, pumpkin, raspberry, strawberry, vanilla bean

step 3 - choose your icing flavor and style

Classic icing flavors

Almond, caramel, chocolate, chocolate hazelnut, chocolate mint, coconut, cream cheese, hazelnut, lemon, mint, orange, spice, vanilla

Deluxe icing flavors

apple butter, blackberry, black tea, blueberry, cardamom rosewater, chai, cherry, coffee, cookies 'n cream*, German chocolate*, golden milk, green tea, lavender, lime, lime coconut, mango, maple, Mexican chocolate, mocha, peach, peanut butter, pineapple, pistachio rosewater, raspberry, strawberry, vanilla bean, whiskey

Icing styles

You’ve picked an icing flavor, now it’s time to customize the icing style! Most of these flavors can be made in a buttercream style or a whipped style. In our bakery, our buttercream is a rich, dense, and fudgie-textured icing and our whipped icing is a lighter and fluffier icing, but not as light as a whipped cream icing. Icings with an * cannot be customized with different icing styles.

step 4 - choose your cake or cupcake size

Choose the cake or cupcake size that best suits your needs! The pricing varies depending on flavors selected. We have two flavor categories for cakes and icings–classic and deluxe. If you select a classic flavor for both the cake flavor and the icing flavor, the pricing will be at the lower end of the spectrum. If you select a deluxe flavor for either the cake flavor, icing flavor, or both, the pricing will be at the higher end of the spectrum.

step 5 (optional) - customize your toppings and fillings

Let’s personalize your cake! Your cake will come with a piped border along the top and bottom edges. This is included in the price and you can choose the color of this border. The pricing for the rest of our toppings and fillings varies. By far our most popular topping is a written message on top of your cake for an additional $2 charge. Some of the other available toppings and fillings are as follows:

Topping options

A customized written message, sprinkles, chocolate chips, coconut, toasted coconut, peanuts, almonds, pistachios, pecans, cookie crumbles, chocolate ganache drizzle, icing roses, or balloons.

Filling options

Customize your cake with a different icing in between the cake layers
Customize your cake with organic preserves in between the cake layers
Torte your cake (slice your cake in half to add additional layers of icing or fillings. Torting is not available for gluten free cakes.)

Custom decoration

Do you have a very specific vision in mind for your cake? Place your cake order over the phone like normal and then let us know that you’d like a price quote for some custom decoration. You will then be directed to email our cake decorator with a description of what you’d like and any inspiration images that you’d like to send. Placing a custom decorated cake order requires a little bit of extra time for communication, so we ask that custom decorated cake orders are placed with at least 10 days notice. All of our custom decorations are hand-drawn flat onto the surface of our cakes using our naturally dyed icings. Any custom decorations will have an additional decoration charge on top of the base price of the cake and this charge will vary depending on the complexity and number of colors used.

step 6 - call us with your order!

Give us a call during our business hours at 614.784.2253 to place your order! Please be patient if our lines are busy and try calling again. We appreciate you working with us to create your special treats!

We request 7 days notice for special order cakes and cupcakes, with an additional 3 days for personalized decoration. Give us a call at 614.784.2253 to see what our availability is and to place your order.